18 Comments
User's avatar
Patterns at the Top's avatar

Your point that people go looking for autonomy and competence when work withholds them fits Sabine Sonnentag's research on recovery from job stress. Two off-job experiences stand out in her studies: mastery, meaning something that stretches your skill, and control, meaning you decide how the time is spent. Both predict lower exhaustion and better wellbeing. A fair test for anyone in a demanding job is whether their week contains one thing they are visibly getting better at.

Steve Magness's avatar

Thanks for adding this. I’ll look into her work.

Patterns at the Top's avatar

Happy to help. A good first step is to pick one skill outside your job and set a small weekly target for it, so the progress is visible.

Mackenzie Hawkins's avatar

Loved that you brought in Self Determination Theory. One of my favorite books -- and people -- is clinical neuropsychologist Dr. Stixrud's Self-Driven Child. (I thinkit's clear enough who is the person and what is the book.) Let's reclaim and redesign for what children really need, and see it wherever it is. 💛

David Andersen's avatar

Fact: Whenever I lost a race on the track I threw hot sauce on the winner.

Steve Magness's avatar

I knew that was you…

David Andersen's avatar

😂

Brandon Webb's avatar

This is the case for giving teenagers real arenas. A kid who has somewhere to compete, fail and get better, a mat, a field, a job, a hard trail, doesn't need to rent one for six hours a night. The Navy was my arena at 18, and I'd have been a menace without it.

Len Shelby's avatar

Great insight and enlightening. “Arena”. This gives me context in my work with Gen Z men.

Steve Magness's avatar

Appreciate it. Glad it was helpful.

Nilesh Kujur's avatar

After dropping out from the Masters degree program in Chemistry and completed the remote job contract in game development. I have decided to give myself two years for challenging my brain, body, and soul.

Monday to Saturday

Mathematics = 2 hours

Drawing and Painting = 2 hours

Photography = 1 hour

Graphic Design = 2 hours

Electronic Dance Music Production = 2 hours

Fluent Hindi Speaking = 1 hour

Athletic and bodybuilding training = 1½ hours

Computer Science = 1½ hours

Leisure = 3 hours (Nowadays, I am using two hours of the leisure time for GTA VI.)

Sunday

Roaming on the streets of Kolkata with no fixed schedule and destination.

Are you playing GTA VI?

Patterns at the Top's avatar

Those blocks add up to about 16 hours a day, which leaves little room for sleep. If you sleep under 7 hours, cut one block by an hour before you cut sleep.

Nilesh Kujur's avatar

I reserve seven hours a day for sleep. This works for me, with no loss of energy until my dinner time.

Brian Tully's avatar

When both my kids (who are rule followers) were little, they loved playing a game where they were put to bed and had to seek out of their rooms. Being able to break the rules in an acceptable manner was a thrill.

And I love your incorporation of availability heuristic. We are seeing it now with tech issues.

Patterns at the Top's avatar

Safe rule-breaking is a good way for kids to practise risk. Try giving them one planned rule-break a week, such as a living-room picnic at bedtime, and see how they handle it.

Dr. Ryan Kasperowitsch's avatar

Huizinga's "arena" is a helpful word for what many young men are missing. You make a strong case that the pull of an open-world game has more to do with autonomy, competence, and relatedness than with violence. I would add the backcountry to the list of real arenas, since effort, risk, and skill there carry consequences a person can actually feel. The sandlot question deserves far more attention than the moral panic ever got. I write about young men, purpose, and leadership at https://drkasperowitsch.substack.com.

Evidence Matters's avatar

What a nuanced and interesting piece! I appreciate how you show the way the cohort studies overrode the lab studies. Fascinating!

Steve Magness's avatar

Thanks! That’s the goal. Interesting and nuanced.