Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Evidence Matters's avatar

I spend my days writing, reading, and reviewing scientific papers. And when I read your posts, I get the energy to get off my couch and go for a run. So good!

Niki Micallef's avatar

Great article! I have two observations and one questions.

Observation 1: It is surprising to me that scientists still try and find “the best”. It’s not that I don’t expect improvements, but it seems obvious to me that there is no one “best” but actually a lot of tools which should be adopted at various stages of training and whose effect will vary depending on the individual and their past training.

Observation 2: You hinted towards it, but time matters. A lot of these studies can do an experiment for X weeks, but it is hard to track over a longer time scale. When you do, there are so many confounding factors which you need to take into account because life is multi-variate, and it’s an output is almost never the result of one input, especially over a longer time range.

Question: Did we figure out everything with regards to training periodisation? We went from only low intensity, to only HIIT and everything in between. We did intervals as short as 6 seconds to multiple minutes. We had people running 40 miles a week and over 200 miles a week. Is there anything else we need to learn when it comes to periodisation, or are we just going to continue cycling between these two extremes forever? Personally, I think that we are better off trying to see the benefits of cross-training or other external factors rather than trying to find the “perfect” periodisation, because it is so individual there is no general “perfect”.

12 more comments...

Ready for more?